HTML, EPUB, and PDF versions are automatically generated. Hello, If not why MDPI did not make publication free of charge as of elsevier and other reputable journals? Is there specific time zone for each deadline of special issues? Or is the academic editor hiring a fourth reviewer? I am sorry to hear that you have been waiting for longer than our estimated time. After two rounds of revision and the status is pending decision since 31st may 2022. Please check your emails. Its unusual that they wouldnt get back to you let me follow this up for you. They will be able to help you. You can get in touch with the editor assigned to your manuscript for specific details. We published a paper in mdpi but after publication, we realized we inadvertently missed authors. The paper has been edited by a native English Editor. English correction done = The paper has been edited for English, which takes about 24 hours. Comment. What might have happened? special issue 12 1 17 -> 2 17 minor revision ( . Thanks very much for the comment. Hope this helps! For Instance I am not a IOAP institue author, but one of my co-author is correspondent to IOAP institute, and the payment mode for his/her IOAP institute is centralised to the university. The reviewer is given 15 days to submit their review. MDPI journals do not discriminate against manuscripts with waivers or vouchers. Most recent answer. I have written to the editorial office to provide us with detailed peer review report since the status is under review. Hi Katherine How can we change or update the uploaded version? It may be that the journal might be waiting to decide based on the theme of the upcoming issue. The first round of reviews usually takes around two to three weeks. Paper accepted = The decision to accept for publication has been communicated to authors and a professional Layout Editor is working on the paper. Hi, I submitted my manuscript 29, July. No changes can be made at any point in the publishing process. Pending major or minor revisions = Author revisions are in progress. Other versions of your manuscript, including HTML, will soon follow. We have been waiting for over five days. Every MPDI manuscript is converted into different formats, ready for publication. Status Associate Editor .Review process , 3 . I have a quary that during Proofread i have done a mistake can I submit it again.if possible then what should be the process. Please reach out to the Editorial Office for more details. Thank you for the comment. after this, the editor says if you insist to add these authors then you should withdraw the paper. Still, I havent gotten any requests for minor or major changes. What could be the reason behind this? I submitted my manuscript to the journal of Materials (materials-2126601) on December 13th. ? We have checked everything, spam or junk folders but no response has every been given (apart from the automatic emails from the journal). You can contact the journal editorial office or the Guest Editors of the Special Issue for specific information. Its important to mention that every manuscript is unique. MDPI will endeavour to consider all circumstances. This manuscript status usually lasts around 12 business days. Your paper is actually going through an open peer review. This stage usually takes 1-2 days, but this can be longer if the Academic Editor has a particularly high workload. Because we have been contacting the SI GE and he showed substantial interest in our paper (even offered us off on the APC), but the paper did not successfully go through the pending review stage. It is a perfect fit with an open SI. Could you like to help me to solve this problem? Then, I resubmitted the manuscript on 1st of October, it went to peer review, two positive responses one with minor revision and second accepted it. This usually takes 2-3 weeks in total. Sometimes, this can take anywhere between 2-6 weeks. Hi What Does My MDPI Manuscript Status Mean? This is because the average waiver rate across all MDPI journals was 35%. They aim to complete it in 1224 hours. While submitting the paper, I pasted an abstract directly from my latex editor that contains dollar signs $ before a number. Since the date of submission, the manuscript is still under the Review status. A summary of the editorial process is given in the flowchart below. Your paper should currently appear as a PDF online. The Academic Editor is making a final decision about your paper. Hi Katherine How can we know if something went wrong with our paper? The duration of this status depends on the Academic Editors workload and availability. You can then apply the feedback to your manuscript and submit the corrections. Sometimes, delays occur when waiting for feedback from reviewers and Academic Editors. The status is now Pending Review. Therefore, kindly check and take the steps. Is there any expedited process, this means extra charge. This stage should take around two weeks, but may take longer depending on how easily we can find reviewers. They will be able to provide an update. As this point is not clear in the website https://www.mdpi.com/apc. This stage involves reaching out to reviewers who are experts in the field. It could be that the Managing Editor needs to re-assess some of the details. The Pending decision status usually takes 1-2 days. After major revisions, when replied to all the comments of the reviewers, and system says upload the manuscript.. after uploading it shows the status of Resubmitted. The APCs currently range from 1000 CHF to 2400 CHF (Swiss Francs). After my paper acceptance i am continuously seeing Pending conversion What is the issue behind. This stage usually takes around 1-2 working days, but is dependent on the editors workload. kindly reply. In fact JCM said the average time for peer review just around 3 weeks! Unfortunately, as soon as the manuscript is accepted for submission, the authors cannot be changed. Pending decision= Academic Editor (48) Pending major or minor revisions= Pending editor decision Academic Editor Paper accepted= English correction done (24: ) We find the automatic answer given to authors after rejected by editor considerably vague and in contradiction with the San Francisco Declaration, which MDPI signed on 2012 with this motto: We aim to publish all manuscripts that are scientifically correct, and do not artificially increase journal rejection rates, allowing the reader community at large to define impact. If this is correct, then what is rejection based on novelty and general significance after rejection by the editor? Dear Torres, thank you for your comment. Hope this helps. As you have been waiting for more than a week, please could you reach out to the Assistant Editor of your manuscript? Weve reviewed your question and have the following information for you. You can also find this information in the Journal Statistics section, accessible via the left-hand menu. MDPI prides itself on the high speed and flexibility of its publication. But one reviewer gave -ve report. This stage might take longer than 1-2 business days, depending on the Academic Editors workload. Yes, you can reach out to the Editorial Office of Polymers and theyll be able to inform you as to why there might have been a delay. I submitted a manuscript last month and it was under review and then pending editor decision. You can find this information on MDPIs SuSy platform. I encourage you to take a look at the Under review section in this article. 2. They will be able to provide you with an update on your manuscript. Hello, You can upload your revised manuscript by logging in to SuSy, MDPIs manuscript submission system. I believe you are talking about plagiarism. This stage usually takes about 1-5 working days. Our Editorial Office may agree to extended revision time, provided that the authors send their request to the in-house Assistant Editor. can you please tell me the reason why it has been rejected, so that i can correct it and resubmit it. To find their details, please go to the journal webpage, and click Editorial Office in the left-hand navigation menu. The charge will therefore be dealt with by your colleagues institution. You can find their details by visiting the journal webpage and clicking Editorial Office in the left-hand column. Could you please contact the guest editor/assistant editor on our behalf to know the problem? My manuscript is (Pending a decision). The same reviewers from the first review will take another look at your manuscript. You can keep up with updates to your manuscript by logging onto MDPIs SuSy. Once youre clear on the ins and outs, get in touch with the Editorial Office, and theyll process your request. I am going to submit my academic paper for my PhD degree. Please could you get in touch with the Sustainability Editorial Office for further information? In fact, in 2022, the average waiver rate across all MDPI journals was 35%. Yes. Unfortunately, you cannot directly edit a manuscript once it has been submitted. Thanks for the comment. Click Editorial Office on the left-hand side. How can i do that, madam/sir. Once you are logged in, you can access your manuscript submission. At MDPI, we try to find 23 professional and efficient reviewers within the first week of sending out invitations. This problem cant affect or confuse the result and description. Therefore, you can submit your paper. It is already more than three weeks since my manuscript was submitted, but there is still no feedback from editorial office and the status is still Under review. Id encourage you to get in touch with the Editorial Office soon to make this happen. This will tell you all you need to know about this status. It usually takes around 48 hours. few more things I want to confirm.. you have commented You can include additional authors at any time during revisions (before manuscript acceptance). nearly one month ago on the blog. The status for my sustainability-1961792 is showing Pending editor decision since 3rd Nov 2022. Regarding your procedure, it takes 1-2 days to display the final decision. I actually think this is unnecessary but the managing section editor request an update of the published paper on the basis of my mail. Regarding the CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy), what to do if two of the co-authors have the same initials (first and last names)? The status is under review. The status changed to pending editor decision on November 24, 2022 and has remained Pending Editor decision since then. You are welcome to choose the same or another MDPI journal if the paper was rejected and you were encouraged to resubmit. pending editor decisionpending611 ~ TA 1 2021-02-21 10:52 - 6 Android 2 2021-02-21 16:50 1 ~ 20 3 2021-04-21 18:52 1 4 2021-04-28 15:27 I have contacted you privately about this matter; please check your spam and junk folders. Thanks for getting in touch! We wanted to remove and add authors. I am afraid we spent a lot of time on review. You can find their details on the journals webpage, by clicking on Editorial Office on the left-hand navigation menu. Under review = The paper is being peer-reviewed. One month ago, I have submitted the Manuscript to Polymers Journal. Hello. Sorry that this is taking a bit longer than expected. You are therefore encouraged to use the journals Microsoft Word template or LaTeX template (including Overleaf) to prepare your manuscript. However, the status of my submitted article is in the pending decision. Please could you contact the Academic Editor for an update? They can give you the details. At MDPI, we want to ensure that the submission process runs as smoothly as possible for our authors. We always try to provide a decision as soon as possible, but we rely on external academic editors for that. Many thanks for the comment. Layout editing, as well as a plagiarism check, are offered at a fixed price. This is unusual of MDPI (data), since the usual time for first review is normally 39 days. As to reply back after paper submission by 2-3 days if accepted. After 2 rounds of the revision, 2 reviewers accept for the publication and 3rd one reject it, because he/she comments irrelevant to the manuscript and authors were not able able to satisfy him/her. If you have introduced an error in the proofreading stage, it is important for you to reach out to the editorial office and the Assistant Editor who is handling your manuscript to inform them of this. But if go through the link the editorial decision is showing rejected and redeclined submission. MDPI has one of the most straightforward and efficient publication processes in the whole publishing landscape. Every manuscript is unique, and some may need additional reviews. We aim to find expert reviewers within one week of sending out invitations and then expect reviews back within two weeks. Could you please advise me how to deal with this situation? MDPI Submission Process: Your Questions Answered, Getting Involved with the Editorial Process Q&A, How to Advance as an Early Career Researcher, Challenges and Opportunities: Early Career Researchers, How to Reduce Stress Whilst Waiting for Publication, MDPIs Policy Regarding Corrections and Retractions. You should review the feedback on SuSy. However, there is an editor comment saying that the manuscript lacks novelty and has limited significance. They will be able to give you an update. Humbly request you Madam, kindly your value-added inputs with regard to the same. If it is missed during the proof read? It usually takes 1-2 days. or Will there be any weightage with regard to the Review Report sent by Round-1 Reviewers? Around 12 business days. Author proofreading = Typographic, image quality, references order, callouts or similar layout and language edits have been made, or are being suggested, for authors to review and confirm. Thanks a lot. This manuscript status indicates that a paper has been pre-checked and is now being peer-reviewed. You can simply email them back, in the same thread where they provided you with the first proofreading. However, the Assistant Editor will continue to contact reviewer candidates until enough reviewers agree. If youre still waiting after a week, please could you get in touch with the Editorial Office? I would encourage you to review the feedback on why your manuscript was rejected. Manuscripts that include plagiarism are rejected. This takes around 24 working hours, but can vary depending on staff schedules. Therefore, we received positive comments from three reviewers in the first and the second revision round. We have a 24-hour window for this step. MDPI waives around a quarter of its APCs every year and offers one of the most affordable pricing structures in the commercial publishing landscape. This takes priority for Assistant Editors. thanks for your question. In general, social sciences journals have slightly more time-consuming publishing processes than natural sciences journals. They will consider the latest version of the manuscript, as well as the completed peer review process. However, each paper is unique. Hi Islam. What is the procedure? Out of which two reviewers gave +Ve Report 3/4 Stars for all the Evaluation parameters. The status is still Pending Review. I have contacted with the editorial office but I did not get response. I have replied to reviewers comments for the second time today. Here is a short video on manuscript status in Editorial Manager, and some additional articles on the manuscript submission process. I hope that you will be fine. It usually takes 12 days. If youre struggling with this, you can reach out to the Academic Editor assigned to your paper, who can add the vouchers before the paper is accepted. According to information from this link, https://susy.mdpi.com/user/manuscripts/review_info/d8d533bff6b18e38e4163b53dc1d5e14 , the submission decision days is 38 days and based on information from the website https://www.mdpi.com/journal/metals , it is said that manuscripts are peer-reviewed and a first decision provided to authors approximately 16 days after submission; acceptance to publication is undertaken in 3.3 days. However, we have not been receiving any response. If my manuscript has been rejected by Optics Letters, can I still submit it to an MDPI publication. They can provide you with an update on your manuscript and put your mind at ease. I submitted an article to microorganisms. please advise. If you still dont notice any updates, please get back in touch. i submitted my revised manuscripts after 2 major revision and one minor revision . Could you please reach out to the journals Editorial Office? Pending conversion = Microsoft Word or LaTeX is being converted to JATS XML. The manuscript was submitted on January 17, 2023. Thank you. 2- Did I receive email if the current status change to Pending major or miner. I think it is not fear that we has pass the blind review pass and now after acceptance the managing editor decided that they are not accepting our changes regarding author addition. As you have been waiting for longer than a week, please could you contact the Editorial Office for an update? This status also applies to second review rounds (revised version reviews). Hi, I have submitted my manuscript on 29, September 2022. Can we publish an erratum correcting it? None of the steps or processes are outsourced, allowing us to maintain close control of the quality and efficiency. Unfortunately, I found one correction didnt match which i told like just adding three words in literature section. Hello Katherine Bosworth! Mistakes do happen and we have a system in place to keep published research up to date and accurate. If you find yourself waiting any longer, please do reach out to the journals Editorial Office. Hi Prof. Mallikarjuna, thank you for the comment. Also another point, the process is so long than before do you know why? For authors from low- and middle-income countries, waivers or discounts will be granted on a case-by-case basis. Thanks and regards. But, I think it is unnecessary so can I cancel the request for an update madam? Plz, reply me. Typically, abstracts are online 2-3 days after publication, with the article showing up shortly thereafter. Submissions to Special Issues undergo the same rigorous peer review process as regular submissions to the journal. Thank you for your comment! Once a manuscript has been submitted, it will go through different stages of progress on SuSy. Please contact the Assistant Editor if you require an extension. Another query is sticking in researcher mind whether voucher based payments increase paper rejection or slows down editorial processing. Thanks for reaching out. On 14 Nov 2022, I could see all the R three Peer Review Reports (Round -1). I will keep in contact with you via email. Our paper had pending editors decision status for 8 days then the status changed to revised version review. If possible, could you help to reach editorial office on my behalf. You can find this feedback on SuSy, MDPIs manuscript submission system. We also submitted a short text as per instructions given at :https://www.mdpi.com/authors/promoting. This is very surprising to hear. You can find their details by clicking Editorial Office on the left-hand column of the journal webpage. It is a comprehensive, web-based software that allows editors to handle all aspects of publication, from initial The Manuscript ID is horticulturae-2253134. But not publishing online yet. If you submit without using an MDPI template, the Assistant Editor will help you with the layout during paper processing. Although some papers pass through the process and hit all the time estimates, others may take longer, for many different reasons. The papers got desk rejections and the same work is not accepted by IEEE Q1 journals. how long would it takes to review. Because today is the 44th day after my first submission date and the status of my article is still unchanged. Author proofreading resubmitted = Authors have resubmitted the latest version of their paper, and the Assistant Editor will accept changes and double-check that everything is correct before paper publication. Regarding the significance, our survey is very important for dentists to find out shortages and limitations of Thiet practice and try to correct and improve. Revised version reviews take about three working days to complete. Even the editorial boards has right to accept any changes or reject but at must be logical. How much time it takes in Pending editor decision? Our in-house editors around the world offer 24/7 services. Pending review = The paper is due to be pre-checked. Hello Manish, thanks for getting in touch. The manuscript will be linked to the previous submission in SuSy. Is it possible to have a waiver from publication fees when I got the acceptance letter. They haven't decided yet. Apologies for the wait. We hope that this breakdown helped you to understand your manuscript status. Its usually only a paragraph or two. Any feedback will be helpful. I have a question related to IOAP institution The Assistant Editor will accept the final changes and double-check that everything is correct before the paper is published. Check out our article on manuscript statuses for more information. Please get in touch with the Economies Editorial Office. Hello, Can authors also track the status of submitted manuscript. For more details on your specific case and an update on your manuscript, please reach out to the JCM Editorial Office: https://www.mdpi.com/journal/jcm/editorial_office. Some may have other commitments, meaning that the reviews are submitted late. So sorry that you have such conflicting information! I already submitted our manuscript and it was under review. I have submitted my manuscript titled to Polymers journal on March 09, 2022 and the revisions were submitted on November 14, 2022. Our article is in the same status from the last 7 days. However, if your paper has already been published, it will have to remain in open review. I even send an email to the new journal editor to ask but not responding. It is first time for me to face this issue in MDPI as I published a lot of papers in MDPI journals and the decision was take after 2days. Make sure to review the rejection feedback in SuSy and apply it to your manuscript, if applicable. This manuscript status means that your manuscript has officially been accepted for publication. Contributions should be listed during the submission process and are also part of the journal template. They should also tell us on advance during the review stage. Today I checked as its changed to Pending decision and I see peer reviewers comments. Reviewers who accept a review invitation are provided 7-10 days to write their review via our online platform, SuSy. With this in mind, I have reached out to Metals on your behalf and I am following your case very closely. Authors pay a one-time Article Processing Charge (APC) to cover the costs of peer review administration and management, the professional production of articles in PDF and other formats, and the dissemination of published papers in various venues, in addition to free readership and other publishing functions. Can we add and remove the author during proofreading step? Take a look at our article on MDPI manuscript statuses for more info. The IOAP entitles authors to a 10% discount on APCs. If you need more details about your case, in particular, the assistant editor assigned to your manuscript can help with that. I submitted the manuscript 6 days ago but still, but it is showing Pending Review Ive read that pending review takes around a few days and I should contact you if it takes more than 5 days. We have waited for more than five days. If I submitted an article in mdpi and 3 reviewers review the manuscript. Why check for update logo is not appeared in some paper? What does it mean? I want to know if this decision was made by the SI GE or others. Thank you for your comment. Hi, How long does this process take to complete? However, authors should consider in advance whether they have sufficient funds to cover the APC. You may include others ideas and words, as long as you quote and reference them appropriately. The Editorial Office is waiting for your revised manuscript. Greetings! Answer: When the status for a manuscript changes "Under Review" to "Ready for Decision", it means that the peer-review process is complete and only the editorial decision is pending. However, I have not yet received a response from the editorial office. This status means that the Academic Editor is making a final decision about your manuscript. A final decision is now being made about your paper. They may be able to suggest other options. They can advise you on this. Is it normal to wait for such a long time. You can find the median publishing pipeline times for each journal in the section Rapid Publication on the journals webpage. Hello Katherine. Not necessarily. Your paper is being converted to HTML and PDF. Authors retain the rights to their published content. We submitted the manuscript entitled, A Study of Chinese Cemeteries in Singapore Case Studies of the Creation and Development of Communal Cemeteries of As you have been waiting for over a week, we will investigate and prioritise this issue. Your last chance to make any edits to the paper is the author proofreading stage. Under review = The paper is being peer-reviewed. Still, it is under review. I submitted my paper on Deecmber 19th and after one month of review , the status is showing as pending decions since more than 5 days after one round of review. Hi Madam, Hi there Syed. Is it possible to re summit manuscript in same journal? Its also important to remember that authors who have their manuscript rejected are refunded the APC. Please contact them to resolve the issue. But, Im happy to inform you that, as your colleague is part of an IOAP institute, the APC will be discounted. Last decision: Reject Reviewer 3 Ole Jonny Klakegg Major (Report sent on 13 October 2020) Last decision: Reconsider after major revision. What should I do to get the editor to take another look at this paper? Special Issue deadlines are by date only. We are sure you will get better answers and possible solutions from her. This is done in much the same way as when you initially uploaded your paper. It usually takes 15 days. I would like to know the status of our manuscript jtaer-2220409 Rather, it refers to the final decision by the Editor-in-Chief (EIC). thanks. MDPI is a different publisher. You can also check out one of our other articles to find out more about what your manuscript status means. It has been two weeks since the status Revised version review. What does its mean after proofreading submission? one reviewer gave major revision and another reviwer gave minor. I hope you could help me on this. Hi, Once they are satisfied with the improvements, your paper will move to the next stage in the publication process. . I contact with assigned editor, but I did not got response. Tq. The status Resubmitted means that you have now uploaded your revised manuscript. Thank you very much for answering my previous comment. The Horticulturae Editorial Office will be able to help you withdraw your manuscript. Thank you very much for your comment. but There are some mistakes in manuscript. For updates related to your article, please contact the editorial office of the journal that you submitted to. Click on Editorial Office in the left-hand navigation bar. A professional Layout Editor is now working on the formatting. Please I will know, In the process revising my paper i am suppose to accept the change suggested by the editor or I should just fix my part. Im from Palestine (where the world considers it as a low-bank country) and Im a PhD student. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Manuscripts submitted with vouchers and/or discounts are processed in exactly the same way as those without. I have published a few papers in Sustainabiltiy, and had several rejected. Yes, you should include this information at the end of your manuscript. JAMS is the submission system behind MDPI's journals. can I ask to remove my name from the article authors list, before the manuscript is accepted?