what is douglass tone in the second paragraph

address to the Rochester Ladies Anti-Slavery Society for the Fourth of July celebrations in 1852, when His speech in this paragraph is hypocritical disparagement about the government 's actions relating to slavery . In the narrative, Douglass gives a picture about the humiliation, brutality, and pain that slaves go through. The Full Document, Kami Export - Natalianna Ferrara - Analyzing Texts Fredrick Douglas Fourth of July.pdf, AUDREY SANCHEZ VILLANUEVA - Analyzing Texts Fredrick Douglas Fourth of July.pdf, Vision College of Education,, Samungli Town, Quetta, Analyzing_Texts_Fredrick_Douglas_Fourth_of_July.pdf, Newcomb_LaNiaya_Frederick_Douglass_Slave4th_JulyGuided_Reading, Analyzing_Texts_Fredrick_Douglas_Fourth_of_July, Copy of Frederick Douglass POV Analysis (1).pdf, It should I think be stated at the outset that the words or witnessing in the, logical steps to figure out specifics deductive reasoning Which statement is, tro Poroshenko and other senior Ukrainian officials have requested shoulder, evenifthepersonwhoistheobjectofthethreatdoesnotobserveorreceiveitsolongas, Social Media Campaign Proposal - Paper.docx, paraneoplastic-syndromes-diagnosis-oncology-rebelem-original.jpeg, Correct Answer C Explanation The scenario implies you have conducted the Control, You should consider our business and prospects in light of the risks and. In the narrative Douglass effectively uses rhetorical imagery, antithesis, and irony in order to expose the harsh reality of slavery during the 19th century. 1842), father of Charles Remond Douglass (b. He also contributed to her pamphlet protesting the exclusion of exhibits dedicated to African American culture from the 1893 Worlds Columbian Exposition, The Reason Why the Colored American Is Not in the Worlds Columbian Exposition. claim in this speech? In the second paragraph , Douglass uses a hypocritical tone . Jamaica uses literary devices to achieve the tone. "the conduct have fueled the fire to fight for abolition or it could have to lend credibility and additional support to their conclusion, WORD STUDY (Gettysburg) The diction of the piece supports imagery relating to which of the following? "you boast of your love of libertywhile the whole nation (Declaration of Independence) Which of the following indicates the subject and the predicate (verb) of the first sentence? 3. "the character and conduct of this nation What is the tone in Frederick Douglass? Douglass argues that slavery has a horrible effect and it is a bad thing. The slave song was focused on the "Great House Farm" since slaves saw it as the highest privilege a slave could achieve. Teenage Douglass experienced harsher living conditions with Auld, who was known for his abusive practices. He articulates his mournful story to anyone and everyone, in hopes of . 5. reproach before God and the world. Douglasss contributions to the Black American community and American history were recognized in the early 20th century during Negro History Week, the predecessor of Black History Month, which many communities anchored to the day on which his birthday was celebrated, February 14. im KSH You may rejoice, I must As an adult, Douglass learned that his mother had been the only Black person in what was then Talbot county who could read, an extraordinarily rare achievement for a field hand. Frederick Douglass was a prolific writer and a masterful orator who captivated readers and listeners throughout the U.S. and Great Britain. Explain. a. refutes its assertion b. offers a qualification c. explains its purpose d. challenges its authenticity e. supports its argument, DIDION 2. Lloyds plantation functioned like a small town. Douglass does use a range of figurative language devices throughout his writing. that he had, in fact, stolen my ladder. to demonstrate that incentive is the driving force behind cheating Omissions? (A) brief, passing odor To expound on his desires to escape, Douglass presents boats as something that induces joy to most but compels slaves to feel terror. It forges a link with past events and ideals. In the book In Cold Blood by Truman Capote, Capote blantly describes the murderous acts of two men who killed an entire family they knew nothing about. View The Latin prefix counter- comes from the Latin contra and means, "against." Then he writes, "the children of slave women shall in all cases follow the condition of their mothers"? mention of liberty for France; but are as cold as an iceberg at This placed him at odds with Stanton and Anthony. Tone is defined as the general attitude of a piece of writing. Chapter 1: 1} Examine Douglass" writing for diction Q&A The effect of choices of words that Douglass uses Thomas Auld, became Douglasss owner. shouts of liberty and equality, hollow mockery; your prayers B. counterexample I will not discuss further your national After the Freedmans Bank debacle, Douglass held numerous government appointments. Write the letter for the correct definition of the italicized vocabulary word. Our editors will review what youve submitted and determine whether to revise the article. Douglass would publish two additional newspapers during his life, Douglass Monthly (185963) and New National Era (187074). He learned to read and write, escaped to the A very important tone present shown through the novel is emotional. He became a recruiter for the Massachusetts 54th, an all-Black infantry regiment in which his sons Lewis and Charles served. Why does he use the word "whisper" in this sentence? Q. politicians at home. (Gettysburg) In the second paragraph Lincoln appeals to which of the following? What is the effect? His distinguished photographs were deliberate contradictions to the visual stereotypes of African Americans at the time, which often exaggerated their facial features, skin colour, and physical bodies and demeaned their intelligence. SETL, f morality represents the way we would like the world to work and economics represents how it actually does work, then the story of Feldmans bagel bu bodyguards of the tyrants of Virgin and Carolina. Douglass uses imagery to inform to convey the cruel treatment of slaves. Thus, option (D) is correct. Tone, the general character or attitude the author has towards a piece of writing. Although Frederick Douglass was an enslaved man, he teaches himself to read and write. Articles from Britannica Encyclopedias for elementary and high school students. His prominence and work resulted in his being the most photographed American man in the 19th century. (Shakespeare) The second paragraph is developed through the use of examples to prove the claim that above all else geniuses are. What is the effect of this tone on his . Through Douglasss use of figurative language, diction and repetition he emphasizes the cruelty he experiences thus allowing readers to under-stand his feelings of happiness, fear and isolation upon escaping slavery. Particular words and phrasing choices that support this tone is ".Above your national joy, I hear the mournful wail of millions!" ".the character and conduct of this nation never looked blacker to me than on this day!" educated man. This resource encourages students to write a rhetorical analysis essay. (a) What general purpose do you think Alvarez had in writing this essay? Then, accent the room with colorful pillows or rugs these items are less costly to update. During the American Civil War Frederick Douglass served as an adviser to Pres. Thomas Auld was the son-in-law of Douglasss owner, Aaron Anthony. Above your national joy, I hear the mournful wail of millions!." (2). (Gettysburg) The first sentence of the Gettysburg Address serves which of the following purposes? She bequeathed the home and its belongings to the organization in her will. pardon Mr. Lincoln pressed his hand warmly, saying: "Mr. Douglass, I am glad to meet you. freedom. and hymns, your sermons and thanksgivings, with all your the Brown invited Douglass to participate in the planned raid on the federal arsenal in Harpers Ferry, Virginia (now in West Virginia), which Brown hoped would inspire a massive uprising by enslaved people. "By this cunning arrangement, the slaveholder, in cases not a few, sustains to his slaves the double relation of master and father" (p. 2). nation seems equally hideous and revolting. Get a Britannica Premium subscription and gain access to exclusive content. New York City was a dangerous place for enslaved people seeking freedom. not? The newly minted Frederick Douglass earned money for the first time as a free man. The countrys tension around slavery rapidly increased in the 1850s. He explains that slaveholders often impregnate their female slaves. Abraham Lincoln's Second Inaugural Address was delivered on March 4th, 1865 during the fourth year of the Civil War. While this revolution gathered steam, with slaves often running away from their masters and finding shelter in swamps, lakes or in cities that believed in their cause, more organized forms of opposition, led by reformers like William Garrison (Document E), who founded The American Anti-Slave Society, also started gaining traction. How did Frederick Douglass become involved in the abolitionist movement? 1839), father of Frederick Douglass, Jr. (b. Posted by July 3, 2022 keto crab rangoon with mozzarella cheese on what is douglass tone in the second paragraph July 3, 2022 keto crab rangoon with mozzarella cheese on what is douglass tone in the second paragraph So spoke Frederick Douglass soon after he heard Abraham Lincoln's Second Inaugural Address on March 4, 1865. slavery and the Fugitive Slave Laws were still legal in the United States. difference between citizens and enslaved people. It destroys your moral power abroad; it corrupts your The Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, written by Frederick Douglass himself, is a brutally honest portrayal of slaverys dehumanizing capabilities. Douglass continued his learning in secret, by exchanging bread for lessons from the poor white boys he played with in the neighbourhood and by tracing the letters in Thomass old schoolbooks. Consequently, Douglass spent his first years in Massachusetts working as a common labourer. you boast of your love of liberty, superior civilization, and At the meeting, abolitionist William C. Coffin, having heard Douglass speak in New Bedford, invited him to address the general body. Although the date of his birth was not recorded, Douglass estimated that he had been born in February 1818, and he later celebrated his birthday on February 14. Living and working conditions were better under Freeland; however, Douglass still desired his freedom. He became the first Black U.S. marshal in 1877 when he was appointed to that post for the District of Columbia by Pres. o You must make clear, full reference to the literary work and author you are What Was Frederick Douglasss Position on Womens Rights? What is Douglass' tone in the second paragraph? Am I called upon to bring our humble fortifications awaiting a The Clutters were good people who had no intention on hurting anyone. In the narrative, Douglass gives a picture about the humiliation, brutality, and pain that slaves go through. We can evidently see that Douglass does not want to describe only his life, but he uses his personal experiences and life story as a tool to rise against slavery. Frederick Douglass Argument Against Slavery 442 Words | 2 Pages. The two men engaged in an epic two-hour-long physical struggle. What does Douglass mean in this statement? It rekindled the few expiring embers of freedom, and revived within There are many tones observed in this narrative. cannot (enslaved people)? Douglass does this to illustrate the illiteracy of the slaves. He left Baltimore and arrived at St. Michael's in March of 1832. up crimes which would disgrace a nation of savages. The Narrative of the life of Frederick Douglass shows the imbalance of power between slaves and their masters. It informs the reader that Douglass worked with white men to create laws that stopped slavery. Anna arrived in New York several days later, and the two were married by the Reverend J.W.C. American editor, writer, and abolitionist, American human rights lawyer and U.S. attorney general, American journalist and government official. By clearly connecting with his audiences emotions, Douglass uses numerous rhetorical devices, including anecdotes and irony, to argue the depravity of slavery. The first sentence of paragraph 6 does which of the following to the subject of paragraph 5? Douglass invalidated common justification for slavery like religion, economic argument and color with his life story through his experiences torture, separation, and illiteracy, and he urged for the end of slavery. Narrative On The Life Of Fredrick Douglass Ch. Frederick Douglass makes a point to demonstrate the deterioration slavery yields from moral, benevolent people into ruthless, cold-hearted people. Nathan Johnson suggested the name Douglass, which was inspired by the name of an exiled nobleman in Sir Walter Scotts poem The Lady of the Lake. What is the effect of this tone on his audience? Above your national joy, I hear the mournful wail of What is the double relation of master and father? The overall tone shows weariness with the ongoing conflict, while also reaffirming a faith in God's will. The purpose of Douglass's narrative is to inform his audience about what slaves experienced on a day-to-day basis. Covey was the turning-point in my career as a slave. That cheerful eye, under the influence of slavery, soon became red with rage; that. Identify the American values that Douglass In 1889 Pres. In 1863 Douglass visited the White House to meet with Pres. Frederick Douglass realized this follow-ing his time as both a slave and a fugitive slave. Whether we turn to the declarations of the past, or Why or why Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like DIDION 1. DIRECTIONS: In eac Think of the larger themes and purposes of . They weren't celebrated when it was their birthday. B. countercharge A. Please refer to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have any questions. In New Bedford the couple stayed with a local Black married couple, Nathan and Polly Johnson. fraud, deception, impiety, and hypocrisya thin veil to cover Douglass then supported Black male suffrage with the idea that Black men could help women secure the right to vote later. Should Lon expect to be freed from prison? Douglass was born enslaved as Frederick Augustus Washington Bailey on Holme Hill Farm in Talbot county, Maryland. American essayists examine the political, the historical, and the literary; they investigate what it means to be an "American," ponder the means of creating independent and free citizens, discuss the nature of American literary form, and debate the place of . religious parade, and solemnity, are, to him, mere bragging, In The Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, Douglass narrates in detail the oppressions he went through as a slave before winning his freedom. In fact, theme of Smiths first book, the Theory of Moral Sentiments, was the innate honesty of mankind. Is Lon facing banishment? After being falsely accused by my neighbor of stealing his ladder, I leveled a phrasing choices that support that tone. At an 1841 antislavery convention, he was asked to recount his experience as an enslaved person. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. According to Douglass, the children of white masters and female slaves generally receive . Then he states, "and it is the wish of most masters to keep their slaves thus ignorant." This amount of power and control in contact with one man breaks the kindest heart and the purest thoughts turning the person evil and corrupt. At age eight the man who owned him sent him to Baltimore, Maryland, to live in the household of Hugh Auld. The tone of Girl is loving, caring, but strict. Along with four other enslaved men, Douglass plotted to escape north by taking a large canoe up the coast of Maryland and to proceed to Pennsylvania, but their plot was discovered. Douglass strongly promoted this philosophy during the early years of his abolitionist career. Frederick Douglass, born a slave and later the most influential African American leader of the 1800s, addresses the hypocrisy of the US of maintaining slavery with its upheld ideals being freedom and independence on July 4th, 1852. Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like In the first paragraph Douglass writes, "By far the larger part of the slaves know as little of their ages as horses know of theirs" (p.1). I answer: a Corrections? Prior to the eradication of slavery writers like Frederick Douglass sought to free millions of slaves in America. Hugh Auld hired out Douglass to local shipyards as a ship caulker. institutions, while you consent to be the more tools and What is Douglass' tone in the second paragraph? While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. What was Frederick Douglasss childhood like? 3. Douglass develops a very disappointed sounding tone in the second paragraph of the excerpt. allows him to argue that slavery is not a part of American from his very long address. salute them, protect them, and pour out your money to them Benjamin Harrison selected Douglass as the U.S. minister resident and consul general to the Republic of Haiti. He became the first Black U.S. marshal and was the most photographed American man of the 19th century. The second overseer at Captain Anthony's, Mr. Hopkins, is fired after only a short time and replaced by Mr. Austin Gore. KIg-z&=J0IPIdb4CF0<5Y-m1nY8^MvVv~ We]kU[w;g#&vh}W[V^mf)2|1 6UkYpTKLF/SPg_Jy0yqVn4ZyqU}R#Mm,4|jn. receive a pardon. Douglass contrasts the celebration of American citizens to the message have been received on the What is the effect of this tone on his audience? , siness lies at the very intersection of morality and economics. He truly tapped into the readers emotions to allow them a deeper connection with the story. In the first paragraph Douglass writes, "By far the larger part of the slaves know as little of their ages as horses know of theirs" (p.1). Chapter 10 29. Pardon me, allow me to ask, why am I called to speak millions! between us. Douglass would eventually hire out his own time, which meant that he paid Auld a set amount every week but was responsible for maintaining his own food and clothing. sham; your boasted liberty, an unholy license; your national To him, our celebration is a The book also challenged the conventional employment of ghostwriters for slave narratives by boldly acknowledging that Douglass wrote it himself. "Certainly," said Mr. Lincoln. Remember that either word may be used. 189 0 obj <> endobj 215 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[]/Index[189 49]/Info 188 0 R/Length 123/Prev 234473/Root 190 0 R/Size 238/Type/XRef/W[1 3 1]>>stream (Gettysburg) The phrase "we can not hallow" serves which of the following purposes? During Reconstruction Douglass became the highest-ranking Black official of his time and advocated for full civil rights for Black people as well as for women. celebration. Then, write the word that are free states and half of the states are slaved states. Course Hero is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university. urgent abolition is and to highlight how unfairly Black these values with those who cannot informs the reader that Douglass would meet with Lincoln a third time, after the presidents second inauguration and about a month before his assassination. Douglass died in his Cedar Hill home on February 20, 1895. The essay is perhaps one of the most flexible genres: long or short, personal or analytical, exploring the extraordinary and the mundane. How is he sarcastic and derisive? He had little to go off regarding his age and lineage. Frederick Douglass was born in slavery to a Black mother and a white father. (Declaration of Independence) In the second paragraph, which of the following introduces a qualifier? effect that this tone has on his audience is to emphasize how Frederick Douglass was a great writer, but he wasnt always. A)TLJT0k,RT1!zIvD The move to Rochester surrounded Douglass with political abolitionists such as Gerrit Smith. A. Please select which sections you would like to print: Alternate titles: Frederick Augustus Washington Bailey. During the latter years of his life, Douglass remained committed to social justice and the African American community. He described her as tall and finely proportioned, of dark, glossy complexion, with regular features, and amongst the slaves was remarkably sedate and dignified. She died when he was about seven years old. But, such is not the case. Director of Interpretations, Collections, and Education, National Civil Rights Museum. justice, liberty, prosperity and independence, bequeathed When I opened the refrigerator, I got a whiffwhiffwhiff of something that told me that the meat had gone bad. people are being treated compared to White citizens. Douglass states, "My subject, then, fellow-citizens, is AMERICAN SLAVERY. We needed to put more weight in the back of the canoe to hb```a``a`e` B@V gCXr;^#q(f`le`c9l\X,"{ad[( offering to the national alter, and to confess the benefits The main topic was . On July 2nd, people from across Massachusetts will gather at noon on Boston Common near the State House for the 11th annual public reading of Douglass's historic address . 28. He escaped in September 1838 by dressing as a sailor and traveling from Baltimore to Wilmington, Delaware, by train, then on to Philadelphia by steamboat, and from there to New York City by train. B. What does Douglass mean in this statement? Why or why not? In acceptance, Douglass presented his speech in Rochester, New York on July 5th 1852. Today Douglass is renowned not just for his rise from slavery to the highest levels of American society but also for his dedication to challenging the country to recognize the rights of all people and be consistent with its ideals. 4. That same year Douglass was appointed president of the Freedmans Savings & Trust, also known as the Freedmans Bank. In his speech at the 1843 National Convention of Colored Citizens in Buffalo, New York, Black abolitionist and minister Henry Highland Garnet proposed a resolution that called for enslaved people to rise up against their masters. His 1845 autobiography cemented his prominence as an abolitionist. Explain. In America, opposition to slavery started with acts of defiance such as slave resistance, where African American slaves would rebel in several ways to attain greater freedom. What is The blessings in which you, this day, rejoice, Douglass is aghast when he hears people cite the singing as evidence of the slaves' happiness, because, to Douglass, there is no more miserable sound. There Aulds wife taught Douglass to read. The growing opposition to slavery, by both slaves and their white sympathizers, eventually culminated in a determined abolitionist movement that highlighted the plight of so many and galvanized public opinion against an appalling institution. Rhetorical Analysis of Douglass. like water; but the fugitives from your own land you (John Adams) The phrase "uniform of grave hue" is an example of which rhetorical or literary device? and bloody, than are the people of these United States, at What is the effect of choices Farmers would pay slaveholders a monthly fee for enslaved people and take responsibility for their care, food, and lodging. What does Mr. The Narrative settled these disputes by naming people and locations in Douglasss life. She also portrays how she strict she is through her intense use of detail when speaking. These events descrited took place in Baltimore, Maryland. to attempt an infiltration into a foreign metro health emsambulance service; buffalo ranches in washington state; why do mega churches not . Douglass attempted to escape slavery at age 15 but was discovered before he could do so. The threat of capture, as well as the books excellent performance in Europe, prompted Douglass to travel abroad from August 1845 to 1847, and he lectured throughout the United Kingdom. 2017 Heather Crivilare What, to the American slave, is your 4th of July? Douglass' underlying tone is bitter, especially about his white father creating him and then abandoning him to slavery. abolitionist fighting to abolish slavery. According to Douglass, Hugh stated that if a slave were given an inch, he would take an ell [a unit of measure equal to about 45 inches]. In Maryland, as in many other slaveholding states, it was forbidden to teach enslaved people how to read and write. day that reveals to him the gross injustice and cruelty to (Declaration of Independence) In the second paragraph, which of the following phrases signals a rhetorical shift? he knew that they could read and he could not. Young Douglass found himself among several other enslaved children competing for food and other comforts. In 1859 Douglass met with abolitionist John Brown in a quarry in Chambersburg, Pennsylvania. The Narrative quickly became popular, especially in Europe, but the books success contributed to Hugh Aulds determination to return Douglass to the conditions of enslavement. He served in that capacity until 1881, when Pres. Because rushing suggests her moving angrily, the reader understands that Mrs. Auld is upset with Douglass and maybe even fearful of him learning to read. When slavery was abolished in 1865, it was a critical turning point in the journey towards equality for African Americans. 2019 Heather Crivilare She uses characters, setting, plot, point of view and style to establish a tone. 1. an accusation made in turn by someone against their accuser proves that the Fourth of July is not something that should Fellowcitizens! His audience was a seemingly sympathetic one and got to them through rhetorical questions. which he is the constant victim. 9k4Y8@? KN endstream endobj 190 0 obj <>/Metadata 7 0 R/OpenAction 191 0 R/Pages 187 0 R/StructTreeRoot 11 0 R/Type/Catalog/ViewerPreferences 216 0 R>> endobj 191 0 obj <> endobj 192 0 obj <>/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]/Parent 187 0 R/Resources<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI]/XObject<>>>/Rotate 0/StructParents 0/Tabs/S/Type/Page>> endobj 193 0 obj <>stream 5 10). Identify particular word or phrasing choices that support that tone. Douglass makes clear his tone of understanding, the theme of both the slave and the slaveholder being affected, and the mood of the reader being. In January 1834 Douglass was sent to William Freelands farm. It outlines how expensive and difficult it was for whites to own slaves. Support your answer. the thought of liberty for the enslaved of America. each sentence. While living with Freeland, he started a Sabbath school at which he taught area Blacks how to read and write. B. counterattack In paragraph 7, Didion suggests an association between which of the following pairs as . It has been seven years since Douglass lived with Master Thomas Auld, and Douglass is soon reminded of the cruel spirit of Thomas and his wife. The existence of slavery in this country %PDF-1.7 % What is Douglass' tone in the second paragraph? declare, with all my soul, that the character and conduct B. counterforce Douglass was owned by Capt. Why does he tell this story? Sources However, despite Douglasss previous work experience, racial prejudice in New Bedford prevented him from working as a ship caulker (white caulkers refused to work with Black caulkers). Explain. against the This outcome may surprise some peopleincluding Feldmans economist friends, who counseled him twenty years ago that his honor-system scheme would never work. what is douglass tone in the second paragraph marana middle school sports June 29, 2022. herself to be false to the future. the rese I am He and other persons who had escaped conditions of enslavement frequently described their own experiences under those conditions. Douglass uses flashbacks that illustrate the emotions that declare the negative effects of slavery. (C) sharp sound In January 1833 Douglass was leased to local farmer Edward Covey. After both Aaron Anthony and his daughter Lucretia died, her husband, Capt. Douglass' tone in the second paragraph is critical and offended. I need the first 4 questions answered in a paragraph and it is all in the the first chapter of the Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass. Douglass is consistent as he addresses how cruel slaves were treated by the white man and sets the state of poverty as the tone. He also says that he is willing to sacrifice reputation and fame for the truth. The follow is a very short excerpt I shall be glad to meet him." The gentleman returned, and soon Mr. Douglass stood face to face with the President. argument. Douglass dedicated himself to securing the communitys rights to this new freedom. I do not hesitate to Douglass recalls the Captain frequently whipping Douglass's Aunt Hester. not a nation of the earth guilty of practices, more shocking The rich inheritance of Let us know if you have suggestions to improve this article (requires login). In 1851 the paper merged with the Liberty Party Paper to form Frederick Douglass Paper, which ran until 1860. Frederick Douglass, original name Frederick Augustus Washington Bailey, (born February 1818, Talbot county, Maryland, U.S.died February 20, 1895, Washington, D.C.), African American abolitionist, orator, newspaper publisher, and author who is famous for his first autobiography, Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave, Written by Himself. Dick and Perry, the murderers, had no reason to do this, meaning they had no motive for these actions and they can not be excused for their actions. Covey represent in Douglass' narrative? What evidence does Douglass provide in this paragraph to support his main claim in this speech? One phrase that helped me identify this tone was, ".

Wayne Hills High School Class Of 1971, Articles W

what is douglass tone in the second paragraph